Payer contract renegotiation means analyzing current reimbursement rates against market benchmarks and Medicare fee schedules, identifying which contracts are underperforming, and negotiating improved rates with payers to increase practice revenue without seeing a single additional patient. Most practices are leaving real revenue on the table because their payer contracts haven't been renegotiated in years. Billed Right provides the data analysis, benchmarking, and strategic preparation practices need to enter renegotiations with confidence.
Why Most Practices Are Underpaid by Their Payer Contracts
Payer contracts are typically signed once and then forgotten. The rate that seemed reasonable at signing gets left unchanged for years while everything around it keeps moving. Practice costs rise, coding patterns evolve as the payer mix and service lines shift, and the benchmark rates other payers are willing to pay drift upward. A contract that was competitive five years ago can be quietly underpaying today, and nothing about the payer relationship forces anyone to notice.
Practices that don't proactively renegotiate aren't just missing an opportunity. They're systematically reimbursed below what the market actually supports for their services, on every single claim, for as long as the contract goes unreviewed. The shortfall shows up as a slightly lower rate on every claim rather than one obvious event, so it rarely gets flagged the way a denial or a billing error would. That's exactly why it can persist for years without anyone catching it.
How Billed Right Supports Contract Renegotiation
- Detailed analysis of current reimbursements by CPT code, diagnosis code, and frequency to identify underperforming contracts
- Benchmarking of current rates against Medicare fee schedules to quantify the gap between current and achievable reimbursement
- Identification of top reimbursement opportunities: the specific codes and carriers with the greatest financial upside upon renegotiation
- Strategic insights into what sets the practice apart, including patient volume, specialty depth, and quality metrics, to strengthen the negotiating position
- Preparation guidance for renegotiation conversations: what to ask for, what to expect, and how to respond to payer counteroffers
- Ongoing monitoring after renegotiation to confirm new rates are being applied correctly by the payer
Billed Right has provided payer contract renegotiation support since 2006, serving practices across the US from our base in Longwood, Florida.
Our Services
Schedule a Conversation
Top 5 Contract Renegotiation Problems We Solve
Contracts Not Renegotiated in Years
Rates agreed to years ago are now significantly below current market benchmarks.
No Benchmark Comparison
The practice doesn't know whether its reimbursement rates are above or below Medicare or market averages.
Underpayments Not Identified
The payer is paying below contracted rates, but the practice has no process to detect it.
No Data to Support Renegotiation
Entering contract talks without CPT frequency analysis or benchmarking data weakens the negotiating position.
Highest-Opportunity Contracts Not Prioritized
The practice renegotiates with the wrong payers first, missing the greatest financial upside.
What to Expect
Analysis
Current reimbursements are reviewed by CPT code, payer, and frequency to identify underperforming contracts.
Benchmarking
Rates are compared against Medicare fee schedules and market benchmarks to quantify the opportunity.
Strategy
Top renegotiation opportunities are identified and prioritized by financial impact.
Preparation
Guidance on positioning, data presentation, and negotiation approach is provided to the practice.
Monitoring
Post-renegotiation rate verification confirms the payer is applying new rates correctly.
Frequently Asked Questions
We analyze current reimbursements by CPT code, payer, and frequency, then benchmark those rates against Medicare fee schedules to find the specific codes and carriers with the greatest financial upside. That way the practice renegotiates the contracts with the most to gain first, not just the ones that are easiest to reach.
We review reimbursements by CPT code, diagnosis code, and frequency to identify underperforming contracts, giving the practice a data-backed picture of exactly where current rates fall short instead of a general sense that reimbursement feels low.
Current contracted rates are compared code-by-code against Medicare fee schedules to quantify the exact gap between what's being paid and what the market supports, turning a vague sense of underpayment into a specific dollar figure per code and payer.
We provide the analysis, benchmarking, and negotiation preparation: what to ask for, what to expect, and how to respond to counteroffers. That gives the practice a strong, data-backed position going into renegotiation conversations.
Timelines vary by payer, but the analysis and benchmarking phase is typically completed well before any renegotiation conversation begins, so the practice isn't waiting on data once the payer is ready to talk.
We help the practice weigh the counteroffer against the benchmarking data and decide whether to push further, hold the line, or prioritize a different contract with a larger opportunity, rather than accepting the first number offered.
More on contract renegotiation.
How to Know When Your Payer Contracts Are Due for Renegotiation, and How to Prepare
A closer look at the signs a contract has fallen behind market rates and what data to gather before opening the conversation.
ReadA/R Recovery Estimator Calculator
Estimate how much additional revenue could be recovered by bringing underperforming payer contracts up to market rate.
Get itHow a Specialty Practice Increased Annual Revenue by Renegotiating Its Top Three Payer Contracts
A composite look at how data-backed benchmarking turned three underperforming contracts into a measurable revenue gain.
ReadReady to Find Out What Your Payer Contracts Are Actually Worth?
Schedule a conversation with our contract renegotiation team. We will review your current reimbursement rates, benchmark them against Medicare fee schedules, and show you exactly where the opportunity is.